SeekGod.ca Discussion Forum

Full Version: Are Heaven and Hell real, or are they mentioned just to scare us?
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
Pages: 1 2
Many under the banner of Christianity are discounting the validity of hell as a place of eternal torment, and heaven is being said to not be a place but rather, Heaven is being taught to be a state of being.

Hell has been described as being the state of those who freely and definitively separate themselves from God. For more quotes regarding these beliefs, please see:

http://www.seekgod.ca/eternity.htm

Are heaven and hell real places?

strefanash

Absolutely.

The Bible says so.

But this raises an interesting question. How do we persuade them to believe the book?

I think the answer is of course in the book, but not in a place i see quoted by apologists

"Father make them one that trhe world may know you have sent the Son".

Because no one lives in their heads, not even intelectuals like me, we are persuaded when we meet that which addresses our need. Likewise we should encounter people where they are at, and this can only happen spiritually when they see the love of christ.

When this is seen people either convert or become outraged.

The trouble is it is easier for us to proffer apologetic argument rather than a love we do not have. in a sense the cultists know this: they dont have the love to offer but they do behave themselves towards unbelievers better than we orthodox and often win converts because of this
. . . . or are they to scare us?

I seriously regard any preaching that sets out to scare people as being evil. As fear destroys faith ands drives men mad (it drove me mad, I kid you not, we deal it out to our peril.

I think of it this way. We are in a ships cabin, a knock at the door one midnight wakes us. A Ships steward says:"Come quickly, the ship is sinking,. follw me to the boat deck. THere is a place for you in the boats, do not panic nor run"

If this were the case we had been warned, but there would be no reason to fear nor to spread fear. THere is a difference between a threat and a warning. If we trusted the steward we would have no fear.

As Jesus said "fear not" we defy him if we try to frighten people into the kingdom. as for me i have heard that vicious excuse "they need it" enough times. And i know false preachers who major in religious terrorism, as I call it

If we respond to heaven or hell in fear we respond in unbelief, and as that which is not faith is sin such a response is sin.

NOTE: sometimes when the word "fear" is used the term " have reverence" is meant. Hebrew, Greek and old english used the same word for both but the difference is crucial.

As for me heaven can wait. The fruit of the Spirit is for here and now, the joy and peace is for now, and it is only to him who has will much more be given

strefanash

(12-19-2008 12:26 PM)Vic Wrote: [ -> ]Hell has been described as being the state of those who freely and definitively separate themselves from God.

If it is a state of being like this , and i do not believe that it is, but if it is, then it is a state of such terror despair and agony that fire is a good metaphor for it. So their point is really void, because such a state of being might, I might suggest, be EVEN WORSE than being burned in lava for eternity. And that is still, I venture, terrifying enough to seek to be saved from it

I have been close enough to madness to see it from the inside, to sample the horror of terror and despair spiralling inward and downward. (Thank God He led me to repent of the sins causing this before they took over) But if this were to carry on for eternity and I were to be damned to hell, I might crave some liquid lava, some physical torture, to take my mind off my mental torment . . . .

http://www.seekgod.ca/forum/images/smilies/confused.gif
:s

Horrible? Think about it . . . or maybe not
(12-26-2008 11:25 PM)strefanash Wrote: [ -> ]I have been close enough to madness to see it from the inside, to sample the horror of terror and despair spiralling inward and downward. (Thank God He led me to repent of the sins causing this before they took over) But if this were to carry on for eternity and I were to be damned to hell, I might crave some liquid lava, some physical torture, to take my mind off my mental torment . . . .

:s

Horrible? Think about it . . . or maybe not

For those of us who belong to God, the thought of hell and what that eternal punishment might be like, may be something we cannot envision. Not to disagree with your point about the spiral of unrepented sin, but once someone dies and they do not have Christ, there is no remorse or conviction of sinfulness. There would only be hatred for God, not the conviction of rejection. If the Holy Spirit convicts the world of sin, in hell there is no Holy Spirit to convict as it would be useless. The time for repentance ceases at the last breath.

Eternal torment, from my perspective, is the terror of knowing that God is not there. With His presence completely absent - there is no hope, no love, no grace, no mercy, nothing but fear, anger/rage, hatred, jealousy, and unimaginable evil - all fueled by an inner depravity that we cannot grasp.

:anyone: what sayest thou?
About hell


I was on the impression hell ment grave like hades ans sheol?
If so and hell and dead is thrown in the lake of fire in the end, there is nomore dead nor graves.
Lake of fire is ready for lucifer(satan) and the angels that took his site.
Is lake of fire a eternal fire, eternal punishment?
Are the dead without Christ eternally in this lake of fire?
These Q's i ask myself.
Humaly spoken i can t imagine a God that torment people for ever and ever, while on the new earth people celebrate love and peace.
I rather think that dead is a not-being.....or without God like you said.But to know that you are without God to feel the emptyness, you must be aware and conscious.
And again it seems so cruel,
but mabey its my human earthly brain. :what:

EMJE

strefanash

(12-26-2008 11:46 PM)sheep wrecked Wrote: [ -> ][quote='strefanash' pid='342' dateline='1230348307']


For those of us who belong to God, the thought of hell and what that eternal punishment might be like, may be something we cannot envision. Not to disagree with your point about the spiral of unrepented sin, but once someone dies and they do not have Christ, there is no remorse or conviction of sinfulness.

I do distinguish between remorse and conviction of sin, and I certainly do distinguish between knowlege of sin and convicton of sin.

Repentant sorrow is totally different from the torment of remorse. I believe I have experienced both. A regret that wil still never repent is different from repentance without regret that St Paul talked about somewhere. I think it helps to remember that Judas Iscariot hanged himself out of remorse, wheras Peter repented out of conviction of sin. Same sin, different response. So to me it can make sense that if we refused the knowledge of sin that God would give us to lead us to repent, our own knowledge of sin would eternally torment us, this being an ungodly response of our own to the fact of our sin. It also seems to me that if the damned will bow the knee at the last judgement, for it is written everyone will declare that Jesus is Lord, then at the Last Judgement will come the final and dreadful conviction of sin (in a different sense of the word) whereby the damned will know full well why they are being sentenced but this knowlege of sin is given without the least shred of mercy.

Like monk shivering in his cell in terror the Last Judgemnent has figured too much in my thought, indeed I thought I had to embrace this type of fear. The words Dies Irae have haunted me for years

But while I totally reject terrorizing people to convert them (and think ill of Jonathan Edward's sinners in the hand of an angry God sermon as well as that local preacher I told you about) the dreadful reality remains and in its proper context the dreadfall warning must be given.

The biggest stumbling block to me as regards believing in a God of love is the terrible reality of hell which I cannot ever deny, but I begin to dimly sense that what terrorized me was false preaching out to terrify, rather than mercy out to warn and save. Those who said they had to be cruel to be kind to me are of their father ther devil.

But this first post of mine here is largely speculative, I was indulging in a gruesome form of irony to make a point. So i cannot really afford to be dogmatic about it
(12-27-2008 12:30 AM)Emjesown Wrote: [ -> ]About hell


.
Is lake of fire a eternal fire, eternal punishment?
Are the dead without Christ eternally in this lake of fire?

And again it seems so cruel,
but mabey its my human earthly brain.

EMJE


I have always thought so, that hell was eternal torment. And it seemed cruel to me. If I have made any headway on this it is by hammering it out with God Almighty himself in prayer.

HE lead me to acknowledge my sense of outrage and claim of injustice in it, to repent of them. At the moment I can live with the reality of hell as I view God as a Holy and Terrible Emperor, The Tsar of Heaven. But this is only a temporary expedient. It is true but not enough. I am SO resistant to the notion that God the Father loves . . . .


But the answer I am headed to is this: Strictly speaking the love of God is not seen so much by the terrible eternal punishment that justice demands, but by his provision to get anyone out of the state of being headed for it, as a free gift.

I am not there yet. So I continue in endless tension and pain, but He is winning the argument and I continue to repentant under his ongoing personal tutelage
Hi all,

What did you think of the Scriptures and discussion within the article
http://www.seekgod.ca/eternity.htm

Will God Say Just Kidding?

I ask this because Jesus said this, repeating the phrases three times:


Mar 9:43-48
(43) And if thy hand offend thee, cut it off: it is better for thee to enter into life maimed, than having two hands to go into hell, into the fire that never shall be quenched:(44) Where their worm dieth not, and the fire is not quenched.
(45) And if thy foot offend thee, cut it off: it is better for thee to enter halt into life, than having two feet to be cast into hell, into the fire that never shall be quenched:
(46) Where their worm dieth not, and the fire is not quenched.
(47) And if thine eye offend thee, pluck it out: it is better for thee to enter into the kingdom of God with one eye, than having two eyes to be cast into hell fire:
(48) Where their worm dieth not, and the fire is not quenched.



Thinking2
My original statment:

Quote:Eternal torment, from my perspective, is the terror of knowing that God is not there. With His presence completely absent - there is no hope, no love, no grace, no mercy, nothing but fear, anger/rage, hatred, jealousy, and unimaginable evil - all fueled by an inner depravity that we cannot grasp.

I need to clarify that - I was referring to mental and spiritual torment in reference to Stref's post, but forgot to tie that in with physical torment ....... my bad Sign0007

Sorry about that Blush

Vic's post nails it, so I concur with those Scriptures concerning the eternal punishment where the flame never dies. As Jesus pointed out in the story of Lazarus and the rich man - it will be physically and mentally torturous.

For those who cannot comprehend that God would torture someone for all eternity, perhaps they should spend time reading the OT [especially 1 & 2 Kings and 1 & 2 Chronicles]. It's not that God hates people, it's that they chose to reject Jesus Christ and have corrupted depraved hearts that refuse to accept or love Him. God sees through the tunnel of time and knows who will reject or accept Him. We cannot grasp His ways, and at the very least, trust that He will judge perfectly at the end of this age.
If what the bible says about heaven is true, then the statements about hell must be real also.

Rev 20:15 And whosoever was not found written in the book of life was cast into the lake of fire.

Matt 23:33 Ye serpents, ye generation of vipers, how can ye escape the damnation of hell?


God does not lie, and lying would include false threats. And God does not speak just to hear his own voice.
(01-27-2010 07:53 PM)Ben Wrote: [ -> ]God does not lie, and lying would include false threats. And God does not speak just to hear his own voice.

Smiley-happy053

I just love how you worded that 8836
Pages: 1 2
Reference URL's