Shepherding & Charismatic Movements
The Scriptural View of the Modern Day Tongues Movement
by Pastor Doug Dugan,
with some editing for clarity by Vicky Dillen
The modern day tongues movement has the element of
excitement, but it lacks the element of Bible authority. Though some erroneously claim that speaking
in the unknown tongue is the evidence of the fulness of the Holy Spirit they do
err in not knowing the Scriptures. The
use of tongues in the Bible was always the use of known languages. The most in depth Bible teaching on the use
of tongues is found in 1 Corinthians 12-14.
These three chapters provide the premier Biblical look at the issue of
tongues. The church of Corinth was a
multicultural church in a multicultural city.
Travelers from all over the world frequented the city.
In the church it would be common to have
people present who had learned two or more languages. These skills were essential to the massive trade business of
Corinth. The practice of speaking in
the church in languages known and used extensively in some parts of the world,
but relatively unknown in Corinth had become a problem. The problem was a pride problem. “Look at me with respect. I have earned it through my diligent study
of languages.” The truth is, we are
still impressed by those that can speak more than one language because most of
have so much trouble with our native tongue.
An “unknown tongue” as used in the Bible is a reference to languages not known
to the speaker, but a language known and practiced by others. The example of Pentecost makes this clear. On the day of Pentecost Peter and the
apostles preached (Acts 2:14). These
men were all Galilaeans (Acts 2:7), most fishermen by trade (Mt. 4:18-19) and
thus largely unlearned. (Acts 4:13).
Yet, on the day of Pentecost the crowd was filled with devout Jews from
every nation under heaven (Acts 2:5).
When Peter and the others preached this international crowd heard them
in their own languages (Acts 2:6).
These many languages and dialects are even listed for us in the chapter
(Acts 2:9-11). The languages heard were
known to the hearers, but not to the speakers.
There was not gibberish being spoken.
This was not babble being muttered, this was the work of God to confirm
that there were no barriers to winning souls to Jesus Christ.
The early church was comprised of Jews that followed Jesus Christ. There was a mindset amongst these Jewish
converts that only Jews within the promised land could be saved. They were not interested in reaching
Gentiles or Jews that had left the promised land. As we read through the book of Acts and even the epistles we see
that there was a constant battle in convincing the early church that they need
not practice Judaism.
Pentecost was the work of the Holy Spirit to convince the early church that
Jews could be saved even if they did not make their residence in the promised
land. Thus Jews from every nation under
heaven heard the Word of God and three thousand were saved, baptized, and added
to the church.
The specific purpose for the gift of
tongues was for a sign, see 1 Corinthians 14:22. "Wherefore tongues are for a sign, not to them that believe,
but to them that believe not: ..."
The use of the gift of tongues was for the purpose of providing a sign
to them that believed not. We learn in
the Scriptures that the first Jewish followers of Jesus Christ had a great
difficulty understanding the offer of salvation was to everyone.
Remember that Jews had been raised to believe that only the Jewish nation was
to be blessed by the Lord. They were
after all God’s chosen people.
Furthermore there was difficulty in accepting that salvation could be
possessed by Jews outside of the Promised Land. The gift of tongues was given as a sign for the purpose of
convincing these first Christians that salvation was available to all, a truth
that these first Christians believed not.
The gift of tongues was given by the Lord to serve a specific
purpose. Every time we find the gift of
tongues being used in the Bible it was to fulfill the specific purpose for
which God had given it. The only
exception to this is in the church of Corinth where they were rebuked for their
man made emotionally driven manifestation of the use of their own manufactured
counterfeit of God's true gift.
The next time we see the Holy Spirit employ the gift of tongues it was as a sign
to the early church that Gentiles could be saved, see Acts 10:34-48. In verses 44-46 of this text we see how
those of the circumcision, Jews, were astonished that the Gentiles could also
receive the free gift of salvation and the indwelling Holy Spirit. Once again we find that this gift was used
for a sign to them that believed not.
It was the early church who believed not that the Gentiles could get
saved and God by this sign showed them differently.
The final time we see the gift of tongues in operation as God intended it to be
used is in Acts 19:1-6. This time we
find the disciples of John the Baptist who had believed John's doctrine and
teaching. The text describes them as
certain disciples. They are described
as such because though they had believed John, they had not yet made Jesus
their Saviour. They were “certain
disciples” disciples of John that had not even heard of the Holy Spirit that
indwells the Believer.
Peter explained that the one whom John spoke of who was to come after John was
Christ Jesus. These disciples
immediately made their decision for Jesus and they were baptized into the
membership of the local body in the name of Jesus. Paul laid his hands upon them and they spoke with other tongues
and prophesied. Once again the sign was
given to confirm that these Ephesian disciples of John the Baptist could be
Simply believing what John had preached concerning repentance and believing on
one who would come after him was not the same as placing one's faith in Jesus
personally. We also see in this passage
that there was no amazement, it is clear that the early church had learned that
everyone needed to be witnessed to and everyone could be saved. It mattered not if they were Jews in or out
of the promised land; it mattered not if they were Gentiles; it mattered not if
they were living in anticipation of the arrival of Him who had already come, if
they would simply place their faith in Jesus Christ they would be saved.
We do not find the Holy Spirit utilizing the gift of tongues any more after
this third time. The next time we learn
of tongues it is by way of Paul's rebuke to the Corinthian church. Tongues were used by the Lord for a specific
purpose...editor--that was to win unbeliever's to the Lord Jesus Christ, by them
hearing 'the things of God', in their own language, so that they might be
saved... The church received the sign of God that all the world could be saved.
editor--We know that God is more than able to give a gift of language to anyone
to proclaim the wonders and truth of God to unbelievers. It is totally under His
discretion and the use and results are totally by God, and are not up to the
person to practice by rote or demand to have it to prove they have the Holy
Spirit. The Biblical gift of 'tongues' is not what is being seen in the
Pentecostal or Charismatic camps.
... The Bible was not yet finished when Paul penned the inspired words of 1
Corinthians and thus he states in 13:9 “For we know in part and we prophesy in
part.” The Word of God was being
completed in parts as Holy men of God spake as they were moved by the Holy
Spirit (2 Peter 1:21). “But when that
which is perfect is come, then that which is in part shall be done away.” 1
Corinthians 13:10 “Perfect” references
the doing away with the “part” mentioned in 1 Corinthians 13:9,10. “For we know in part, and we prophesy in
part.” These parts of the Bible brought
forth through the use of prophecy compiled together as the perfect law of
liberty (James 1:25). The Psalmist
confirms “that which is perfect” is the law of the Lord (Psalm 19:7)...
That which is occurring today in the modern day tongues movement needs to be
rebuked with as much severity as Paul rebuked the pride filled church of
Corinth for counterfeiting a ministry of the Holy Spirit. The gift of tongues had become so useless by
the time Paul wrote to the church of Corinth he said: “Yet in the church I had
rather speak five words with my understanding, that by my voice I might teach
others also, than ten thousand words in an unknown tongue.” (1Co 14:19).
It might interest you to know that satanic cults also speak in what sounds
exactly like the unknown tongues of the Charismatic movement of our day. One example of this is found in the O’
Timothy library and is as follows:
"Throughout Jamaica there is a class of people known as `Pocomania.' This
word means `half-mad or a little mad.' They believe in all kinds of
superstitions and practice all manner of evil. Since they are generally very
poor, they usually worship in the open air. A very common sight here is to see
groups of these people beating their drums and singing on the streets and along
the roads. Last Sunday evening I saw five large groups in about as many city
blocks. Often you can hear their drums beating until late at night. They speak
in tongues and sing our choruses, and because of this it brings a great
reproach upon the true Gospel and makes the preaching of the Gospel
If speaking in tongues is the evidence of the fulness of the spirit then my
question is what spirit? Because the devil’s
crowd is filled with a spirit that moves them to speak in tongues too! Perhaps we should return to Paul’s lesson
for us: “Let all things be done decently and in order.” 1 Corinthians14:10.
Previous Section: Pentecostal Tongues &
"The Inner Ecstasy"
dialogue with a former charismatic, dealing with tongues, see: Memorable
Experience of tongues
Copyright . All articles are the sole property of SeekGod.ca and Vicky Dillen. All Scripture King James Version unless otherwise stated.
Do You KNOW Jesus
Now is the time
to accept Jesus as your Lord and Savior. "Behold now is the
accepted time; behold now is the day of salvation."
If you read only one article on this
please let it be:
Plan of Salvation.
It concerns the most important
you will ever make in your life!
Don't let this
opportunity to be saved pass you by.
If you don't know Jesus Christ as your Lord and
Savior, and would like some help understanding His gift of
eternal salvation, please contact us. Saying a prayer
won't save you. Prayer is merely expressing to God how you
feel. Believing and repenting are just the beginning of
walking with Jesus Christ as Lord and